Hamilton Beach Homepage

Heritage Dish: Rhubarb Custard Pie

In our Heritage Dish series, we feature Hamilton Beach employees and their favorite family recipes. This month, we highlight Pat Schweitzer, consumer test kitchen manager, and one of her favorite family dessert recipes inspired by life on a Jackson, Minnesota farm, Rhubarb Custard Pie.

In our family, it just wouldn’t be spring without mom’s Rhubarb Custard Pie. Tart rhubarb is the perfect complement to the sweet goodness of the custard on the bottom and the crunch of the crumb topping.

I grew up on a farm in southwest Minnesota. My mom Alyce traded in her teaching career to raise fruits, vegetables, chickens and her own brood of five children. At the end of her massive garden was a patch of rhubarb. If you’ve only seen the huge stalks in grocery stores, you have been missing the real thing! Rhubarb is a perennial vegetable that grows like crazy in cool weather, so it’s a natural for early Minnesota gardens. Although considered a vegetable, it’s mostly used like a fruit in desserts and jams. Only the stalk is edible, and the larger it grows, the more woody the stalk becomes and the less desirable it is for cooking.

If you had an abundance of rhubarb, you would make rhubarb cake, rhubarb bread, rhubarb crisp, strawberry rhubarb jam and, if you still had some left, you’d probably pass it on to friends and neighbors whose gardens were less productive. But despite rhubarb’s versatility, none of those treats compared to my Mom’s custard pie. Recently, as I was rummaging through my collection of handwritten recipes, I found four for this pie.I guess I wanted to be sure I had a copy!

My mom will tell you that one of her secrets to a perfect rhubarb pie is the pie pan. It is an all-aluminum deep dish pie pan. According to her, they don’t make them anymore, so she searches rummage sales, and when she finds them, she gives them to my sister, sisters-in-law and me. (Don’t tell her I now have two of them.)

Making this pie is so easy. You just chop up the rhubarb and mix it with eggs, milk, sugar and flour. The recipe cards vary on the amount of sugar, and one version has nutmeg added. I go with the lower amount of sugar and leave out the nutmeg. I prefer it to be pretty tart with the rhubarb flavor as the star. You then pour the mixture into a pastry crust and top it with the crumb topping. After baking, the custard magically sinks to the bottom and the tart rhubarb filling gets sandwiched in the middle by the crumb topping.

Rhubarb Custard Pie

Yield: Serves 8
Author: Pat Schweitzer

Ingredients

  • Pastry for 9-inch pie (Food Processor Pie Crust)
  • 3 large eggs
  • 3 Tablespoons milk
  • 1 3/4 cups sugar
  • 1/4 cup flour
  • 4 cups sliced rhubarb
  • 1/2 cup butter
  • 1/2 cup packed brown sugar
  • 1 cup flour

Instructions

  1. Preheat oven to 425°F.
  2. Prepare Food Processor Pie Crust and place in 9-inch deep dish pie pan.
  3. Lightly beat eggs. Add milk, sugar and flour. Stir in rhubarb. Pour into pie shell.
  4. Mix topping ingredients until crumbly. Spread on top of rhubarb mixture.
  5. Bake 40 to 50 minutes or until knife inserted in center comes out clean. Cool before cutting. Refrigerate remaining pie after serving.

With the Soft Scrape™ Hand Mixer, you can mix without having to constantly stop to scrape the bowl. That’s because its unique Soft Scrape™ attachments thoroughly incorporate ingredients as you mix.

More strawberry and rhubarb recipes

https://blog.hamiltonbeach.com/fresh-strawberry-cake/

https://blog.hamiltonbeach.com/strawberry-rhubarb-upside-down-cake/

https://blog.hamiltonbeach.com/center-stage-icelandic-skyr-waffles-with-rhubarb-syrup-from-savory-tooth/

Related Posts

8 new pasta recipes from some of our favorite influencers

Let us help you take the guesswork out of making fresh pasta at home. We’ve rounded up some of our favorite influencer-created recipes to help you cook perfectly textured and delightfully delicious pasta using the Hamilton Beach® Electric Pasta...

Breakfast, lunch, and dinner with a cast iron electric grill

A new generation of professional chefs and home cooks alike are discovering the tried-and-true benefits of cast iron cooking with the Hamilton Beach® Professional cast iron electric grill. It offers all the upsides of your grandmother’s...

Here’s the scoop: 7 easy homemade ice cream recipes

From rich and creamy chocolate and vanilla ice cream to light and refreshing sorbet, there’s no better way to capture the easy, breezy vibes of summer than with a homemade batch of everyone’s favorite frozen treat. Hamilton Beach has the tools...

Comments

  1. My favorite part of Spring is rhubarb custard pie!! The recipe I have is almost the same as yours. I do like a bit of nutmeg in mine, about half of what my recipe calls for. I also put a lattice top on it, I may have to try it with the crumble this year! Funny you mentioned the pan, I have a glass pie dish passed down from my Grandmother that is the only thing I will use for this pie. Now I am getting hungry for it and impatient for the rhubarb to grow!

  2. Janelle, Recipes from our mothers and grandmothers are the best. They usually add something that makes them special. Ours just might be the pan! Thanks so much for sharing your experience with this recipe.
    Pat

  3. Pat, My Baba used to make a pie similar to this. I remember the creaminess against the tart rhubarb. As much as I like rhubarb this way, my favorite was always this: When I was little, my Gee Gee (grandfather) would send me inside to the kitchen for a half-inch of sugar in a glass. I’d come out with it and he’d give me a stalk of rhubarb to dip into the sugar. Dip. Bite. Chew. Dip. Bite. Chew. Ahhh…summer.

  4. Christine, I used to do that as a child too! The sugar next to the tart rhubarb is what makes it soooo good. Thanks for sharing your memory!
    Pat

  5. My friend just served this pie last evening and it was one of the best rhubarb pies I’ve ever eaten!!!! I just HAD to have the recipe. If you make this recipe I guarantee you will not be disappointed. Five stars!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *